Let us deal first with the title, a parenthetical masterstroke. "If There Was Ever A Fool" promises a solitary dunce, the usual protagonist of the heartbreak ballad. Then the brackets arrive, "(One Of A Cast Of Many)", and quietly sweep the stage clear of sympathy. Nobody here is the sole villain, and nobody is the sole victim. Everyone in the drama is a clown, the narrator included, and the song is all the more humane for admitting it. This is not self-pity dressed up as art. It is something rarer: a shrug with a sense of humour.
The guitar remains the beating heart of it. There is a lived-in quality to the playing, the sound of a man who has spent more than four decades learning precisely when to say something and when to let the silence do the talking. The fact that its seed was an off-the-cuff improvisation lends the whole piece a looseness, a sense of a thought still forming as it's spoken. Around it, the arrangement swells into something properly cinematic. Orchestral sweep, ambient haze and a soulful undertow gather behind him, and the result sits somewhere between a film score nobody commissioned and a rock record that has wandered off to read some poetry. Art pop is the nearest label, though it only half fits, which is as it should be.
The great trick, and it is a trick worth applauding, lies in the friction between sound and sense. The music is grand, dreamy, almost operatic in its emotional reach. The words, by contrast, are wry, sardonic and faintly appalled, the observations of someone who has watched adults behave like children and found it both tragic and hilarious. It is like being handed a lavish velvet curtain and finding a raised eyebrow behind it. Lesser artists would have picked a lane. C'batch drives down the middle of the road and waves cheerfully at both ditches.
Ambition can be a dangerous thing in an independent artist, since it so often outruns resources. Here the scale never feels like overreach, because the song understands what it is doing. It takes its storytelling seriously while declining to take its characters seriously, a balance that has defeated far better-funded records. There is theatre in it, certainly, but it is theatre with a wink, the kind where the audience laughs at the tragedy and then feels a little guilty about it.
Context only enriches the thing. A career stretching across four decades, a catalogue wandering through R&B, soul, rock and jazz-tinged instrumentals, and a recent run of Vault releases excavating his own back pages: all of it suggests an artist who regards time as an ally rather than an enemy. An idea does not expire simply because it was born in 2012. Sometimes it merely waits for its better half. The accompanying video, which promises further cinematic storytelling, only underlines the point.
In an age of disposable singles engineered for thirty-second attention spans, "If There Was Ever A Fool" is a refreshingly stubborn thing: a song with a past, a plot and a point of view. It is rich, strange, funny and oddly tender, and it leaves one wanting to meet the rest of the cast.
A wry, sumptuous and thoroughly charming piece of work from an artist who has clearly earned his eccentricities.
