Indie Dock Music Blog

Latest:
A J Green UK - Before The End (album)              Gilgulim - Soulslike (album)              Peter Manning Robinson - Bent Out of Shape (video)              GLEET - Strident (single)              Zach Adams - Dead Man Walking (single)              Naoko Hiranuma - Sea of Light (single)                         
Energy Whores – Planet B
Carrie Schoenfeld and her New York collaborator Grant have the nerve to ask the question that most pop music is far too comfortable to even approach: not whether we can save this planet, but whether we ever truly believed it needed saving at all. "Planet B" — the latest transmission from their project Energy Whores — arrives not as a protest song, not as a lament, but as something considerably more unsettling: a diagnosis delivered with a synthesiser and a smirk.

The track opens with the kind of atmospheric patience that immediately signals you are not dealing with ordinary electro-pop. Pads bloom and recede like weather systems. A pulse establishes itself with metronomic certainty, as though the song itself has accepted certain inevitabilities before Schoenfeld has even opened her mouth. When she does, the effect is disarming — the vocal sits at an odd angle to the instrumentation, slightly above it, slightly apart, like someone narrating events they are too intelligent to be surprised by.


The "avant electro" tag that Energy Whores apply to themselves turns out to be neither false modesty nor overreaching branding. "Planet B" genuinely occupies a zone between genres that most artists would find uncomfortable. It has the emotional temperature of art rock — the willingness to let unresolved tension sit without resolving it into a reassuring chorus — and the sonic vocabulary of cinematic electronica: lush, immersive, spatially deep. Grant's production is meticulous without ever becoming sterile. Every element earns its place. The drums, when they hit with full force, feel earned rather than imposed.


Lyrically, Schoenfeld is doing something quite precise. The subject is, ostensibly, climate change — that familiar apocalyptic wallpaper of contemporary songwriting. But "Planet B" refuses the genre's usual satisfactions. It is not angry in the way we have been trained to expect anger about the environment to sound. Nor is it hopeful in the cheap, billboard-slogan fashion that pop music tends to reach for when complexity becomes inconvenient. Instead, the song examines the psychological architecture of denial — the very human tendency to believe, against all available evidence, that escape remains possible. That there is always another door. Always a plan B. The irony of the title lands not as a punchline but as a slow, cold realisation.


This is music that understands the difference between urgency and panic. Panic, after all, is ultimately a form of helplessness dressed up as passion. Urgency is something quieter and harder to sustain — it requires the listener to remain present with discomfort rather than be released from it. "Planet B" sustains that discomfort with considerable skill, never allowing the production's genuine beauty to become an anaesthetic.


What separates this record from the considerable pile of well-intentioned eco-anthems is the quality of attention Schoenfeld and Grant bring to the emotional contradictions of the subject. Humanity's relationship with Earth is not simply one of exploitation — it is, far more troublingly, one of love and exploitation simultaneously, of wonder and destruction occurring in the same breath. The song holds those contradictions without flinching. It captures the seduction of looking upward at stars even as the ground beneath us grows less certain.


"Planet B" will not fix anything. It knows this, and does not pretend otherwise. What it offers instead is rarer: a few minutes of genuine reckoning, set to music that is actually worth listening to twice. Energy Whores remain one of the more interesting propositions in contemporary electro art — unafraid of ideas, technically accomplished, and constitutionally opposed to the easy answer. That is, at this particular moment, not a small thing.