Indie Dock Music Blog

Latest:
Ker - Lofty Thoughts (single)              OpCritical - Not Alone (video)              Clay Brown & the Trouble Round Town - Satisfy Your Mind (single)              Delta Fire - Lady Danger (single)              FellowFeel - Shadows and Lies (album)              B.F.S.F - Everyone Everything (album)                         
The Dawn Razor – Chiaroscuro Italiano
Sylvain Spanu's second full-length offering under The Dawn Razor moniker arrives six years after his debut, and the Parisian multi-instrumentalist has clearly spent the intervening period refining his peculiar brand of romantic brutality. *In Sublime Presence* positions itself squarely within the melodic death metal tradition while reaching backward to plunder the aesthetic sensibilities of 19th-century Romanticism—a conceit that could easily collapse under its own pretensions, yet somehow maintains its balance across the album's runtime.

The opening salvo establishes Spanu's compositional approach immediately: crushing death metal foundations overlaid with guitar work that wouldn't sound entirely out of place on a Scandinavian power metal record. This dichotomy forms the album's central tension, and whether one finds it exhilarating or exhausting will largely determine their relationship with the material. The production favors clarity over murk, allowing each element to breathe—a choice that serves the intricate lead guitar passages but occasionally robs the rhythm section of the oppressive weight that makes extreme metal genuinely extreme.


Vocally, Spanu operates primarily in a mid-range growl that carries surprising intelligibility, eschewing the subterranean guttural approach favored by many of his contemporaries. This serves the conceptual framework well; when you're attempting to channel Caspar David Friedrich through a wall of distortion, perhaps it helps if listeners can actually parse your ruminations on the sublime and the infinite. The clean vocal passages that surface periodically add dynamic variation without tipping into the saccharine melodrama that plagues lesser acts attempting this synthesis.


Named for the oceanic point furthest from any landmass, the composition mirrors its subject's isolation through sparse, atmospheric passages that gradually accumulate density before erupting into technical fury. The guitar solo—one of Spanu's showcases—spirals upward with neoclassical flourishes that would make Yngwie Malmsteen nod appreciatively, though whether such approval constitutes recommendation or warning remains deliciously ambiguous.


"Chiaroscuro Italiano," the album's most recent video offering, finds Spanu leaning heavily into his Romantic influences, both musically and presumably visually. The interplay between light and shadow that defined Caravaggio's technique finds its sonic equivalent here in the lurching transitions between melodic passages and crushing palm-muted riffage. It's ambitious, occasionally brilliant, and just pretentious enough to work.


The album's greatest achievement lies in its avoidance of the stylistic homogeneity that frequently afflicts solo projects. Each track maintains its own identity while contributing to the larger conceptual whole. Whether Spanu is channeling the symphonic grandeur of Dimmu Borgir, the technical precision of Children of Bodom, or the groove-oriented heaviness of Gojira—the press materials' chosen reference points—he does so with enough personality to avoid mere pastiche.


The romantic sublime, as understood by Burke and Kant, involved confronting the awesome and the terrible—experiences that simultaneously attracted and repelled, that made one feel simultaneously insignificant and elevated. Spanu grasps this intellectually, translating it through his chosen idiom with admirable commitment. Whether he's entirely captured that visceral, transformative quality remains debatable. The music certainly reaches for transcendence; whether it achieves it depends largely on the listener's willingness to meet the artist halfway.


*In Sublime Presence* marks genuine artistic development from *Renaissances*, suggesting Spanu's best work may still lie ahead. For now, we have a flawed but fascinating document from a musician refusing to accept death metal's self-imposed limitations, someone genuinely trying to expand the genre's emotional and intellectual vocabulary. That ambition alone merits attention, even when the execution occasionally falters. Recommended for those whose metal collection sits comfortably alongside their art history texts.